ABEYTA v. CITY OF ALBUQUERQUE

No. 10-2234.

664 F.3d 792 (2011)

Ben D. ABEYTA; Richard T. Adams; Johnny Aguilar; Erlinda Antillon; Eric Ames; Max Aragon; Leroy J. Archuleta; John Armijo; Angelo Baca; Peter Baca; Priscilla Archuleta; Larry Baca; Juan J. Armijo; Jessica Bachicha; John Barnes; Todd Bartlett; John Robert Bazan; George E. Booker; John Bottyliso; John Bouldin; Carol C. Brady; Shelly Alexis Burlingame; Betty Jo Brooks; Nick D. Candelaria; Anthony Chavez; Samuel Castillo; August C. Chavez; Augustine E. Chavez; Curtis Chavez; Dennis Chavez; Victor T. Chavez; Frank M. Concini; H. Anthony Chavez; Edward R. Chavez; Dion R. Coney; Tony Corriz; Richard L. Debeulieu; Raymond L. Dimas; Richard Dubriel; Orlando S. Duran; Charles Fernandez; Olympia J. Esquivel; Roy W. Freitag; Phillip J. Gallegos; Eric Gandy; Earl Garcia; Ernestine Garcia; Frederick Garcia; Gene R. Garcia; Johnny Garcia; Joseph R. Garcia; Gilbert A. Garcia; Luis Garcia; Manuel Garcia; Pete Garcia; Rosie I. Garduno; Ruben R. Gaytan; John E. Ginan; Willie D. Giles; Angel M. Gomez, III; Lawrence B. Gomez; Mike Gomez; Robert C. Gutierrez, Chairman; John D. Hunter, President; David Lovato; Sandra Clark Lucero; Johnny Gonzales; Johnny B. Gonzales; Gaylene S. Griego; James Hernandez; David A. Herrera; Mary Herrera; Tim Herrera; Philip L. Howard; Precilla M. Jaramillo; Frank J. La Viera; Joseph Linton; Isaac Lopez; Elmer D. Lucero; Leo A. Lucero; Diana M. Marquez; Charlie Martinez; Mary Lou Griego; Lawrence H. Johnson; Mickey Griego; Daniel Maez; Epimenio Martinez; Robert Hernandez; Paul Martinez; Dorothea Montano; Motorcoach Operators; Frank Mc Afree; Mark McDonough; Jaun A. Mejias; Glenn Miller, Jr.; Anthony Don Millet; Ismael F. Montanez; Alex S. Montoya; Sadie C. Montoya; Jose R. Mora, Jr.; Jeff Nickelson; Douglas M. Nuanez; Pete Nunez; Don E. Maxey; Rueben Montoya; Johnny Montoya; Leroy A. Ortega; United Transportation Union Local 1745; Jacob Romero; Dale J. Padilla; Leroy Saavedra; Patricia Sandoval; Charles Osman; Edward T. Otero; Joann A. Otero; Ronald Otero; Atanacio M. Pacheco; Paul Padilla; Cynthia S. Perea; Joe A. Rodarte; David A. Sanchez; Trinnie Sanchez; Antonio Silva; Anthony Simoes; Anselup G. Smith; Shirley Stacy; Michael Tegado; Louis Teitelris; Jeff Valencia; Victor Vega; Steve W. Wright; Joseph A. Ortiz; Cheryl I. Parrett; Rumaldo Ramirez; Alex Ruiz; Jerry Sanchez; Jesus Santiago; Aldrina Sisneros; Victor D. Soltero; Margarita D. Trevino; Mary M. Schall; Michael Toya; Ernest M. Vargas; Robert M. Whalen; Angelo M. Reyes; Buddy L. Rivera; Juan Silva; Edward L. Taylor; Orlando Torres; Dennis Zamora; Eugene P. Perea; Nick Ramirez; Merewyn B. Slag; Andy Torres; Scott S. Swanson; Roger A. Tapia; Delvin Villavicencio; Hugh Zemek; Miachel A. Sanchez; Lawrence J. Pacheco; Daniel R. Otero; Sam Ortiz, Plaintiffs, v. CITY OF ALBUQUERQUE; Lawrence Rael, Chief Administrative Officer; Martin Chavez, Mayor, Defendants. Jennifer Bean; Bean & Associates, Inc., Appellants, v. Paul Steven Livingston, Appellee.

United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit.

December 23, 2011.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

William C. Salmon of Rhodes and Salmon, P.C., Albuquerque, NM, for Appellant.

Paul Livingston , Placitas, NM, for Appellee.

Before O'BRIEN, McKAY, and MATHESON, Circuit Judges.


McKAY, Circuit Judge.

This case comes to us on appeal for the second time and still involves a dispute over payment for transcripts of proceedings in the underlying case. After this court held that Appellant Jennifer Bean had no right to be paid for transcripts that Appellee Paul Livingston, attorney for the plaintiffs in the underlying action, did not order or obtain from her, the district court on remand vacated a court-ordered lien and ordered disbursement of funds...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases