IN RE BARD IVC FILTERS PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION

MDL No. 2641.

IN RE: BARD IVC FILTERS PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION. This Order Relates to: All Actions.

United States District Court, D. Arizona.

February 11, 2016.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Bard IVC Filters Products Liability Litigation, In Re, represented by Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

George Leus, Plaintiff, represented by Amanda Montee , Montee Law Firm, James P Cannon , Montee Law Firm, James Albert Montee , Montee Law Firm, Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Gary Milton, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Robert M Hammers, Jr , Jason Schneider PC, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Denise Ocasio, an individual, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, John J Glenn , Anderson Glenn LLC, Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Wilnar Jeanne Julmiste , Anderson Glenn LLC & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Carmelo Ocasio, an individual, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, John J Glenn , Anderson Glenn LLC, Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Wilnar Jeanne Julmiste , Anderson Glenn LLC & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Casey Wyatt, an individual, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA, Julia Reed-Zaic , Heaviside Reed Zaic, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Lessie Tillman, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, James P Cannon , Montee Law Firm, Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA, Julia Reed-Zaic , Heaviside Reed Zaic, Laura Elizabeth Smith , Heaviside Reed Zaic, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Michael William Heaviside , Heaviside Reed Zaic, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Joseph A Osborne, Jr , Osborne & Associates.

Carol Kruse, an individual, Plaintiff, represented by Richard J Schicker , Schicker Law Firm.

Carol Kruse, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Carol Kruse, an individual, Plaintiff, represented by Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

David L Sizemore, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Michael L Armitage , Waters Kraus & Paul, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Albert Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ryan McCarley , Fears Nachawati PLLC, W Bryan Smith , Morgan & Morgan PA & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Joseph Rowe, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, William H Carpenter , William H Carpenter Law Office Limited & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Tonya Munson, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Nathan Craig Van Der Veer , Farris Riley & Pitt LLP, Richard Arthur Freese , Freese & Goss PLLC, Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, John Pinckney Harloe, III , Freese & Goss PLLC & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Alice Jackson, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Timothy John Freiberg , Freiberg Law Offices & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Anthony Jackson, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Timothy John Freiberg , Freiberg Law Offices & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Angela M Henley, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Kevin R Martin , Martin Law Offices SC, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Humana Insurance Company, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Marcia Roeder, Plaintiff, represented by David W Zoll , Zoll Kranz & Borgess, Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Dawn Merritt, Plaintiff, represented by Clair A Montroy, III , Law Office of Clair A Montroy III, Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA, Laura Elizabeth Smith , Heaviside Reed Zaic, Michael William Heaviside , Heaviside Reed Zaic, Julia Reed-Zaic , Heaviside Reed Zaic & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Debra Branch, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Debra Branch, Plaintiff, represented by Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Debra Branch, Plaintiff, represented by Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Juanita C Graham, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Charles Conn, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Alyssa Conn, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Mary Jo Anderson, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Melissa Ebert, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, John Neumann Hickey , Law Offices of John N Hickey, Joshua A Mankoff , Lopez McHugh LLP, Michael S Katz , Lopez McHugh LLP, John Pinckney Harloe, III , Freese & Goss PLLC, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP, Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Vicki Wetzel, Plaintiff, represented by Michael S Katz , Lopez McHugh LLP, Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Harry Keen, III, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte, Joshua D Miller , Toriseva Law, Michael S Katz , Lopez McHugh LLP, Michael Joseph Ryan , Lopez McHugh LLP, Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Homer W McClarty, Plaintiff, represented by Craig E Hilborn , Hilborn & Hilborn, Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Vicki Rivera, Plaintiff, represented by Craig E Hilborn , Hilborn & Hilborn, Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Brittany Ann Hough, Plaintiff, represented by David B Krangle , Alonso Krangle LLP, Andres F Alonso , Alonso Krangle LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Jason Hough, Plaintiff, represented by David B Krangle , Alonso Krangle LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Pamela B Cason, Plaintiff, represented by Jason T Schneider , Schneider Hammers LLC, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP, Robert M Hammers, Jr , Jason Schneider PC & Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Susan Fox, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher Thomas Kirchmer , Provost & Umphrey Law Firm LLP, Elizabeth Hosea Lemoine , Wick Phillips Gould & Martin LLP, Jamie Jean McKey , Kendall Law Group LLP, Jody Lynn Rudman , Kendall Law Group LLP, Joe Kendall , Kendall Law Group LLP, Julia Reed-Zaic , Heaviside Reed Zaic, Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Jessica Deserio-Mintz, Plaintiff, represented by Andres F Alonso , Alonso Krangle LLP, David B Krangle , Alonso Krangle LLP, Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Robert Mintz, Plaintiff, represented by Andres F Alonso , Alonso Krangle LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Jennifer R Coker, Plaintiff, represented by Kimberly w Grant , Grant Law Office, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP, Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Wayne Grant , Grant Law Office.

Joel A Coker, Plaintiff, represented by Kimberly w Grant , Grant Law Office, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Wayne Grant , Grant Law Office.

Pamela Noterman, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel C Burke , Parker Waichman LLP, Jordan L Chaikin , Parker Waichman LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Heather Blacketer, Plaintiff, represented by Brandon L Corl , Potts Law Firm LLP, Patricia Lynn Campbell , Potts Law Firm LLP, Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Christopher Cronan, Plaintiff, represented by Louisa O Kirakosian , Waters Kraus & Paul, Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Shannon Cronan-Castellanoes, Plaintiff, represented by Louisa O Kirakosian , Waters Kraus & Paul, Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Melonee Murray, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas S Saeltzer , Walkup Melodia Kelly & Schoenberger, Matthew D Davis , Walkup Melodia Kelly & Schoenberger, Michael A Kelly , Walkup Melodia Kelly & Schoenberger, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Spencer J Pahlke , Walkup Melodia Kelly & Schoenberger.

John Murray, Plaintiff, represented by Douglas S Saeltzer , Walkup Melodia Kelly & Schoenberger, Matthew D Davis , Walkup Melodia Kelly & Schoenberger, Michael A Kelly , Walkup Melodia Kelly & Schoenberger, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP, Spencer J Pahlke , Walkup Melodia Kelly & Schoenberger & Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Thomas Fregeau, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Thomas A Kenefick, III , Law Office of Thomas A Kenefick III & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Maureen Fregeau, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Thomas A Kenefick, III , Law Office of Thomas A Kenefick III & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Sandra Scott, Plaintiff, represented by Clyde Talbot Turner , Turner & Associates PA, Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Debra Green, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA, Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Luis Castillo, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Clifford Geter, Plaintiff, represented by Nathan Craig Van Der Veer , Farris Riley & Pitt LLP, Richard Arthur Freese , Freese & Goss PLLC, Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC, John Pinckney Harloe, III , Freese & Goss PLLC, Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Debra Castellano, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA, Julia Reed-Zaic , Heaviside Reed Zaic, Laura Elizabeth Smith , Heaviside Reed Zaic, Michael William Heaviside , Heaviside Reed Zaic, Joseph A Osborne, Jr , Osborne & Associates & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Jessica Parker, Plaintiff, represented by Nathan Craig Van Der Veer , Farris Riley & Pitt LLP, Kenneth Riley , Farris Riley & Pitt LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

David Shackleford, Plaintiff, represented by Laura Elizabeth Smith , Heaviside Reed Zaic, Michael William Heaviside , Heaviside Reed Zaic, Peter Thomas Anderson , Ashcraft & Gerel LLP, Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA, Joseph A Osborne, Jr , Osborne & Associates, Julia Reed-Zaic , Heaviside Reed Zaic & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Erin Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher Thomas Kirchmer , Provost & Umphrey Law Firm LLP, Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Ernest Winland, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte, Robert D Rowland , Goldenberg & Heller PC, Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law, Joshua D Miller , Toriseva Law & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Carol Jo Winland, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte, Robert D Rowland , Goldenberg & Heller PC, Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law, Joshua D Miller , Toriseva Law & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Lisa Schweska, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte, Robert D Rowland , Goldenberg & Heller PC, Joshua D Miller , Toriseva Law, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Daniel P Schweska, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte, Robert D Rowland , Goldenberg & Heller PC, Joshua D Miller , Toriseva Law, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Donald Epps, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte, Peter C Wetherall , Wetherall Group Limited, Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law, Joshua D Miller , Toriseva Law & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Robert Peery, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte, Ricky L Boren , Hill Boren, Joshua D Miller , Toriseva Law, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Emily Landress, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Robert M Hammers, Jr , Jason Schneider PC, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Joji Takada, Trustee in Bankruptcy for John Noonan, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob W Plattenberger , Torhoerman Law LLC & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

John Noonan, Plaintiff, represented by Jacob W Plattenberger , Torhoerman Law LLC & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Michelle Mercurio, Plaintiff, represented by Hadley L Matarazzo , Faraci Lange LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Claudette Y Mears, Plaintiff, represented by Anthony James Urban , Urban Law, John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte, Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law, Joshua D Miller , Toriseva Law & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Lisa Smullen, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA, Julia Reed-Zaic , Heaviside Reed Zaic & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Angela Voigt, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte, Lawrence R Murphy, Jr , Richards & Connor, Mariann M Robison , Richards & Connor, Joshua D Miller , Toriseva Law, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Pharris Morgan, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte, Joshua D Miller , Toriseva Law, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Billy C Morgan, Jr., husband, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Billy C Morgan, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte, Joshua D Miller , Toriseva Law, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Denise O'Neil, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Matthew Robert Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Tamika Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA, Roberts Clay Milling, II , Henry Spiegel Milling LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Myra Edwards, Plaintiff, represented by John Lacoste Langdoc , Baron & Budd PC, Laura J Baughman , Baron & Budd PC, Roland Karim Tellis , Baron & Budd PC, Russell W Budd , Baron & Budd PC, S Ann Saucer , Baron & Budd PC & Sindhu Daniel , Baron & Budd PC.

Catherine Rowden, Plaintiff, represented by Christopher J Quinn , Driscoll Firm PC, John J Driscoll , Driscoll Firm PC, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP, Andrew D Kinghorn , Driscoll Firm PC & Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Mary Duffie, Plaintiff, represented by Howard L Nations , Nations Law Firm, Michael Brandon Smith , Childers Schlueter & Smith LLC & Stephen Grant Daniel , Nations Law Firm.

James Duffie, Plaintiff, represented by Howard L Nations , Nations Law Firm, Michael Brandon Smith , Childers Schlueter & Smith LLC & Stephen Grant Daniel , Nations Law Firm.

Kevin Gross, Plaintiff, represented by Margaret Moses Branch , Branch Law Firm, Turner Williamson Branch , Branch Law Firm & Adam Tal Funk , Branch Law Firm.

Jennifer Campbell Tate, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Mathew R Doebler , Pribanic & Pribanic LLC & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

William Owens, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Joseph Jacob Zonies , Reilly Pozner LLP, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Sheila Middleton, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin, Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin & Timothy John Freiberg , Freiberg Law Offices.

Dean Becker, Plaintiff, represented by Elaine T Byszewski , Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro LLP, Leonard W Aragon , Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro & Robert B Carey , Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro LLP.

Cheryl Rouse, Plaintiff, represented by Alex C Park , Law Office of Alex C Park.

Karen Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Felecia L Stern , Bernstein Liebhard LLP, Raymond Joseph Kramer, III , Torhoerman Law LLC & Sandy A Liebhard , Bernstein Liebhard LLP.

Norma J Dukett, Plaintiff, represented by Steven D Davis , Toerhoerman Law LLC.

Michael Callahan, Plaintiff, represented by Ellen Relkin , Weitz & Luxenberg PC, Marlene J Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC & Stuart Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC.

Priscilla Callahan, Plaintiff, represented by Ellen Relkin , Weitz & Luxenberg PC, Marlene J Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC & Stuart Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC.

Joanna Darwactor, Plaintiff, represented by Joshua S Whitley , Smyth Whitley.

Donald E Yates, Plaintiff, represented by Frederick R Hovde , Hovde Dassow & Deets LLC & John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte.

Joy E Yates, Plaintiff, represented by Frederick R Hovde , Hovde Dassow & Deets LLC & John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte.

Tammy Lynn Hillsburg, Plaintiff, represented by Michael T Gallagher , Gallagher Law Firm.

Christine Lorthe, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA.

Audrey R Keegan, Plaintiff, represented by Gerard C Kramer , Schmidt Ronca & Kramer PC & Jon C Conlin , Cory Watson Attorneys.

Kendrick Taylor, Plaintiff, represented by Laura J Baughman , Baron & Budd PC & Russell W Budd , Baron & Budd PC.

Debra P Rodrigue, Plaintiff, represented by Bruce S Kingsdorf , Barrios Kingsdorf & Casteix LLP, Dawn M Barrios , Barrios Kingsdorf & Casteix LLP & Zachary Logan Wool , Barrios Kingsdorf & Casteix LLP.

Mark A Rodrigue, Plaintiff, represented by Bruce S Kingsdorf , Barrios Kingsdorf & Casteix LLP, Dawn M Barrios , Barrios Kingsdorf & Casteix LLP & Zachary Logan Wool , Barrios Kingsdorf & Casteix LLP.

Priscilla Eaker, Plaintiff, represented by Rhett A McSweeney , McSweeney Langevin LLC.

Thomas Eaker, Plaintiff, represented by Rhett A McSweeney , McSweeney Langevin LLC.

Nannette Smith, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Patricia Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Roberts Clay Milling, II , Henry Spiegel Milling LLP.

Tommy Lee Beal, Plaintiff, represented by Elizabeth G Grimes , Law Offices of Michael A DeMayo LLP & Jon C Conlin , Cory Watson Attorneys.

Jennifer Shropshire, Plaintiff, represented by Thomas K Herren , Herren & Adams & Yvonne M Flaherty , Lockridge Grindel Nauen PLLP.

Gary Leigh Piazza, Plaintiff, represented by Wendy R Fleishman , Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein LLP & Daniel E Seltz , Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein LLP.

Freedom Zybert, Plaintiff, represented by Troy Alexander Brenes , Brenes Law Group.

Alec Caldwell, Plaintiff, represented by Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Robert G Harbridge, Plaintiff, represented by Alexandra V Boone , Miller Weisbrod LLP, Les Weisbrod , Miller Weisbrod LLP & Max Freeman , Miller Weisbrod.

Michael Gill, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Lynn Ann Agnew, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

James Edward Agnew, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Linda Lue King, Plaintiff, represented by Donald A Migliori , Motley Rice LLC, Fred Thompson , Motley Rice LLC & John C Duane , Motley Rice LLC.

Regina Kinney, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

James Kinney, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Marie Dolan, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Cynthia Bruhn, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Rick Reed, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Phillip Batchelder, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Kim Batchelder, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Michelle R Layman-Hanes, Plaintiff, represented by Rand P Nolen , Fleming Nolen & Jez LLP.

Michael King, Plaintiff, represented by Moze Cowper , Cowper Law.

Wilford L Edwards, Plaintiff, represented by Monte Bond, 74650 , Tautfest Bond PLLC.

Karen S Thomas, Plaintiff, represented by Brian A Goldstein , Cellino & Barnes PC.

Debbie Anderson, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Vivian Baldwin, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Anders Linster, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Denise Gill, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Mark Seaman, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Dona Seaman, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Paula Peters, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Brett Waliczek, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Elizabeth Waliczek, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

April Buracker, Plaintiff, represented by Moze Cowper , Cowper Law.

Maygret Wood, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

John Bradshaw Wood, III, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Jamie M Barrow, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Tammy Hesser-Schluter, Plaintiff, represented by Adam Tal Funk , Branch Law Firm, Margaret Moses Branch , Branch Law Firm, Turner Williamson Branch , Branch Law Firm & Eric M Terry , TorHoerman Law LLC.

Bradley Ricker, Plaintiff, represented by Carrie R Capouellez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Florence Bures, Plaintiff, represented by Carrie R Capouellez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Michael S Katz , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Roger B Knotts, Plaintiff, represented by Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Vanice Knotts, Plaintiff, represented by Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

John L Kuhn, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Jodi Smith, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Jay Brian Madson, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Linda Madson, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

George Borden, Plaintiff, represented by Charles R Houssiere, III , Houssiere Durant & Houssiere & Randal A Kauffman , Houssiere Durant & Houssiere.

Melody Borden, Plaintiff, represented by Charles R Houssiere, III , Houssiere Durant & Houssiere & Randal A Kauffman , Houssiere Durant & Houssiere.

Thomas P Torpey, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Michael Viola, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Corrina M Hardeman, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Nicole Elizabeth Gross, Plaintiff, represented by H Forest Horne , Martin & Jones PLLC.

Michael Alan Gross, Plaintiff, represented by Michael Alan Gross

Stephanie Grygiel, Plaintiff, represented by Gregory N McEwen , McEwen Law Firm Limited.

Amber Nordin, Plaintiff, represented by Michael F Marlow , Johnson Miner Marlow Woodward & Huff PLLC.

Dezarae Anzaldua, Plaintiff, represented by Annesley H DeGaris , DeGaris Law Group LLC, Daniel Seltz , Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein, LLP & Wendy R Fleishman , Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein LLP.

Deborah Kucharski, Plaintiff, represented by Annesley H DeGaris , DeGaris Law Group LLC, Daniel Seltz , Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein, LLP & Wendy R Fleishman , Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein LLP.

Kirsten Bicica, Plaintiff, represented by Laura J Baughman , Baron & Budd PC & Russell W Budd , Baron & Budd PC.

Kimberly Curry, Plaintiff, represented by Laura J Baughman , Baron & Budd PC & Russell W Budd , Baron & Budd PC.

Cheyenne Carter, Plaintiff, represented by Laura J Baughman , Baron & Budd PC & Russell W Budd , Baron & Budd PC.

Judy Gibson, Plaintiff, represented by Laura J Baughman , Baron & Budd PC & Russell W Budd , Baron & Budd PC.

Patty King, Plaintiff, represented by Laura J Baughman , Baron & Budd PC & Russell W Budd , Baron & Budd PC.

Robert Dougal, Plaintiff, represented by Laura J Baughman , Baron & Budd PC & Russell W Budd , Baron & Budd PC.

Susan Hayes, Plaintiff, represented by Laura J Baughman , Baron & Budd PC & Russell W Budd , Baron & Budd PC.

Farah E Radjewski, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Mary L Faulk, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Deborah A Kaiser, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Lorene M Crowe, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Terry J Harless, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Ivana L Hudson, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Rhonda V White, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Russell J Webster, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Jered J Salmon, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Bernard Pikal, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Roger Lee Presswood, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Timothy A Barnett, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Lenore B Lieberman, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

James Dustin Kouns, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

James Anthony Carlyle, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Jason Lee Perkins, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Jacob Richardson, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Andrea Jean Richardson, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

James Brassard, Plaintiff, represented by Marlene J Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC & Stuart Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC.

Jamie Brassard, Plaintiff, represented by Marlene J Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC & Stuart Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC.

William T Jones, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Sherly Fairchild, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Johnny Kestner, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Matthew Smith, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Patricia Levy, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

William Levy, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Heather E Miller, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Tiffany C Burns, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Lishus R Gore, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Saundra B Green, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Kathleen Frame, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Ramiro V Soliz, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Lucille A Kowalczyk, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Allen Gene Erlitz, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Sally Ann Erlitz, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Cristal Morris, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Gary Tomlinson, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ryan McCarley , Fears Nachawati PLLC.

Sheryl Harvey, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Michael Williams, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Kelly Williams, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Beth Hardenbrook, Plaintiff, represented by Marlene J Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC & Stuart Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC.

Ron Hardenbrook, Plaintiff, represented by Marlene J Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC & Stuart Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC.

Joyce A Smith, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Margaret Owens, Plaintiff, represented by Marlene J Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC & Stuart Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC.

Willie Owens, Plaintiff, represented by Marlene J Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC & Stuart Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC.

Cindy Terry, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Janet A Kimbro, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Tammy Lopez, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

James E Henry, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Daniel W Hodge, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Gale Robinson, Plaintiff, represented by Marlene J Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC & Stuart Goldenberg , Goldenberg Law PLLC.

Chastity Sepulveda, Plaintiff, represented by Hadley L Matarazzo , Faraci Lange LLP.

Michael L Guarino, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA.

Audrey I Kasler, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA.

Martha Mendes, Plaintiff, represented by Graham B LippSmith , Kasdan LippSmith Weber Turner LLP & Jaclyn L Anderson , Kasdan LippSmith Weber Turner LLP.

Pamela Bingham, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA.

James E Pugh, Plaintiff, represented by David P Matthews , Matthews & Associates & Sheila M Bossier , Freese & Goss PLLC.

Mary Hudson-Pierce, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA.

George Pierce, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA.

Sonia K Nunn, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Ryan Wilson, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA.

La'Trina Harris, Plaintiff, represented by Joseph R Johnson , Babbitt & Johnson PA.

Debra Tinlin, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

James Frances Tinlin, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Audrey Valente-Kropf, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

John Kropf, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Eileen Schmuck, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Kevin Schmuck, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Nathan Anastasoff, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

George Borden, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Melody Borden, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Wanda Faye Jensen, Plaintiff, represented by C Lincoln Combs , Gallagher & Kennedy PA, Mark Stephen O'Connor , Gallagher & Kennedy PA & Paul Lincoln Stoller , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Wanda Faye Jensen, Plaintiff, represented by Robert W Boatman , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

Wanda Faye Jensen, Plaintiff, represented by Shannon L Clark , Gallagher & Kennedy PA.

David Troulliet, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Joseph Catlin Mixson, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Virginia Breann Mixson, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

John Anderson, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ryan McCarley , Fears Nachawati PLLC.

George M Hahn, Plaintiff, represented by Eric M Terry , TorHoerman Law LLC & Tor A Hoerman , TorHoerman Law LLC.

Concepcion Lopez, Plaintiff, represented by Eric M Terry , TorHoerman Law LLC & Tor A Hoerman , TorHoerman Law LLC.

Paul Kerbel, Plaintiff, represented by Eric M Terry , TorHoerman Law LLC & Tor A Hoerman , TorHoerman Law LLC.

David Allen Ruck, Plaintiff, represented by Eric M Terry , TorHoerman Law LLC & Tor A Hoerman , TorHoerman Law LLC.

Shirley M Doze-Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Rand P Nolen , Fleming Nolen & Jez LLP.

David Light, Plaintiff, represented by Eric M Terry , TorHoerman Law LLC & Tor A Hoerman , TorHoerman Law LLC.

Ronald Moody, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Patricia Kilcran, Plaintiff, represented by Daniel C Burke , Parker Waichman LLP.

Goldie Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Naomi Brewer, Plaintiff, represented by Graham B LippSmith , Kasdan LippSmith Weber Turner LLP & Jaclyn L Anderson , Kasdan LippSmith Weber Turner LLP.

Gerald Copple, Plaintiff, represented by Jennifer Nolte Williams , Jackson Allen & Williams LLP.

Gerald Copple, Plaintiff, represented by John H Allen, III , Jackson Allen & Williams LLP.

Robert Paschal, Plaintiff, represented by Troy Alexander Brenes , Brenes Law Group.

Dawn M Hendrickson, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Stephen E Hendrickson, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Janice L Blakley, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Thomas Mallory, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Linda R Mills, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

James B Mills, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Randy Nelson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric M Terry , TorHoerman Law LLC & Tor A Hoerman , TorHoerman Law LLC.

Sara J Evers, Plaintiff, represented by John A Dalimonte , Karon & Dalimonte & Teresa C Toriseva , Toriseva Law.

Shirley Dance, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Dana Daniels, Plaintiff, represented by Ben C Martin , Law Offices of Ben C Martin & Thomas William Arbon , Law Offices of Ben C Martin.

Bianca Fraser-Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Neilli M Walsh , Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor LLP, Richard A Zappa , Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor LLP & Timothy E Lengkeek , Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor LLP.

Michael Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Neilli M Walsh , Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor LLP, Richard A Zappa , Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor LLP & Timothy E Lengkeek , Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor LLP.

Dodi Froehlich, Plaintiff, represented by Troy Alexander Brenes , Brenes Law Group.

Valencia Allen, Plaintiff, represented by Troy Alexander Brenes , Brenes Law Group.

Wayne Ruden, Plaintiff, represented by David R Ongaro , Ongaro PC, David Raymond Ongaro , Ongaro PC, Glen Elliot Turner , Ongaro PC, Kirsten McNelly Bibbes , Ongaro PC & Nevin Christopher Brownfield , Ongaro PC.

Brent Dewitt, Plaintiff, represented by Matthew Ramon Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP & Ramon Rossi Lopez , Lopez McHugh LLP.

Barbara Van Sciver, Plaintiff, represented by Annesley H DeGaris , DeGaris Law Group LLC, Daniel Seltz , Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein, LLP & Wendy R Fleishman , Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein LLP.

Wesley Edwards, Plaintiff, represented by John Lacoste Langdoc , Baron & Budd PC, Laura J Baughman , Baron & Budd PC, Robert R Hatten , Patten Wornom Hatten Diamonstein LC, Roland Karim Tellis , Baron & Budd PC, Russell W Budd , Baron & Budd PC, S Ann Saucer , Baron & Budd PC & Sindhu Daniel , Baron & Budd PC.

C R Bard Incorporated, Defendant, represented by Aaron A Clark , McGrath North Law Firm, Alex Cameron Walker , Modrall Sperling Roehl Harris & Sisk PA, Amanda Christine Sheridan , Snell & Wilmer LLP, Andrew J Trevelise , Reed Smith LLP, Angela M Higgins , Baker Sterchi Cowden & Rice LLC, Brandee J Kowalzyk , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC, Catherine A Faught Pollard , Quarles & Brady LLP, Christopher Brian Watt , Reed Smith LLP, Daniel C Burke , Parker Waichman LLP, Daniel K Winters , Reed Smith LLP, David J Cooner , McCarter & English LLP, David W Ledyard , Strong Pipkin Bissell & Ledyard, David J Walz , Carlton Fields Jorden Burt PA, Debra A Djupman , Reed Smith LLP, Diana Rabeh , Reed Smith LLP, Edward W Gerecke , Carlton Fields Jorden Burt PA, Elizabeth S Fenton , Chamberlain Hrdlicka, Elizabeth C Helm , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC, Eric J Buhr , Reed Smith LLP, Gary Robert Tulp , McCarter & English LLP, James P Catalano , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP, James R Condo , Snell & Wilmer LLP, James F Rogers , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP, Jane T Davis , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP, Jennifer Ann Guidea , Reed Smith LLP, Jennifer J Hageman , Ulmer & Berne LLP, John A Camp , Carlton Fields Jorden Burt, John Andrew LaBoon , Segal McCambridge Singer & Mahoney Limited, John G Mitchell , Secrest Wardle, Jordan L Chaikin , Parker Waichman LLP, Kara Trouslot Stubbs , Baker Sterchi Cowden & Rice LLC, Kevin M Hara , Reed Smith LLP, Kevin George Lohman , Reed Smith LLP, Lyn Peeples Pruitt , Mitchell Williams Selig Gates & Woodyard PLLC, Mark A Sentenac , Reed Smith LLP, Matthew E Brown , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP, Matthew B Lerner , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC, Melanie M Atha , Cabaniss Johnston Gardner Dumas & ONeal LLP, Melissa Dorman Matthews , Hartline Dacus Dreyer & Kern LLP, Michael Kevin Brown , Reed Smith LLP, Neville H Boschert , Jones WalkerWaechter Poitevent Carrere & Denegre, Patrick T Clendenen , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP, Raymond G Mullady, Jr , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP, Richard B North, Jr , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC, Ruth A Horvatich , McGrath North Law Firm, Sanjay Ghosh , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC, Steven James Boranian , Reed Smith LLP, Taylor Tapley Daly , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC, Thomas Melone , Allco Renewable Energy Limited, Tiffany L Roach Martin , MNodrall Sperling Roehl Harris & Sisk PA & Vivian M Quinn , Nixon Peabody LLP.

Bard Peripheral Vascular Incorporated, Defendant, represented by Aaron A Clark , McGrath North Law Firm, Alex Cameron Walker , Modrall Sperling Roehl Harris & Sisk PA, Amanda Christine Sheridan , Snell & Wilmer LLP, Andrew J Trevelise , Reed Smith LLP, Angela M Higgins , Baker Sterchi Cowden & Rice LLC, Brandee J Kowalzyk , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC, Catherine A Faught Pollard , Quarles & Brady LLP, Christopher Brian Watt , Reed Smith LLP, Daniel K Winters , Reed Smith LLP, David J Cooner , McCarter & English LLP, David W Ledyard , Strong Pipkin Bissell & Ledyard, David J Walz , Carlton Fields Jorden Burt PA, Debra A Djupman , Reed Smith LLP, Diana Rabeh , Reed Smith LLP, Edward W Gerecke , Carlton Fields Jorden Burt PA, Elizabeth S Fenton , Chamberlain Hrdlicka, Elizabeth C Helm , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC, Eric J Buhr , Reed Smith LLP, Gary Robert Tulp , McCarter & English LLP, James P Catalano , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP, James R Condo , Snell & Wilmer LLP, James F Rogers , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP, Jane T Davis , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP, Jennifer Ann Guidea , Reed Smith LLP, Jennifer J Hageman , Ulmer & Berne LLP, John A Camp , Carlton Fields Jorden Burt, John Andrew LaBoon , Segal McCambridge Singer & Mahoney Limited, John G Mitchell , Secrest Wardle, Kara Trouslot Stubbs , Baker Sterchi Cowden & Rice LLC, Kevin M Hara , Reed Smith LLP, Kevin George Lohman , Reed Smith LLP, Lyn Peeples Pruitt , Mitchell Williams Selig Gates & Woodyard PLLC, Mark A Sentenac , Reed Smith LLP, Matthew E Brown , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP, Matthew B Lerner , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC, Melanie M Atha , Cabaniss Johnston Gardner Dumas & ONeal LLP, Melissa Dorman Matthews , Hartline Dacus Dreyer & Kern LLP, Michael Kevin Brown , Reed Smith LLP, Neville H Boschert , Jones WalkerWaechter Poitevent Carrere & Denegre, Patrick T Clendenen , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP, Raymond G Mullady, Jr , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP, Richard B North, Jr , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC, Ruth A Horvatich , McGrath North Law Firm, Sanjay Ghosh , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC, Steven James Boranian , Reed Smith LLP, Taylor Tapley Daly , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC, Thomas Melone , Allco Renewable Energy Limited, Tiffany L Roach Martin , MNodrall Sperling Roehl Harris & Sisk PA & Vivian M Quinn , Nixon Peabody LLP.

Christian Mottas, an individual, Defendant, represented by David J Walz , Carlton Fields Jorden Burt PA.

Christian Mottas, Defendant, represented by Edward W Gerecke , Carlton Fields Jorden Burt PA & Matthew B Lerner , Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLC.

Christiana Care Health Services Incorporated, Defendant, represented by Christine Kane , White & Williams & John D Balaguer , White & Williams.

Christiana Care Health Systems Incorporated, Defendant, represented by Christine Kane , White & Williams & John D Balaguer , White & Williams.

Thomas Bauer, Defendant, represented by Christine Kane , White & Williams & John D Balaguer , White & Williams.

California Pacific Medical Center, Defendant, represented by Hilary E Youngblood , Davidovitz & Bennett.


Defendants C. R. Bard, Inc. and Bard Peripheral Vascular Services, Inc. ("Bard") seek a protective order to prevent Plaintiffs from using the December 15, 2004 report of Dr. John Lehmann. Doc. 306. The issues are fully briefed (Docs. 379, 412), and the Court heard oral argument on January 29, 2016 (Doc. 507). The...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases