REICH v. STATE OF NEW YORK

Robert B. REICH, Secretary of the United States Department of Labor, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. STATE OF NEW YORK, Defendant-Appellant. Gerald J. LONG; Paul L. Piwinski; Denis J. Donovan; Robert P. Faynor; John J. Tonzi; Donald E. Brandstetter; Douglas C. Field, individually and on behalf of others similarly situated; John F. Ahern; William M. Ambler; Daniel J. Arcuri; Norman Ashbarry; Niles J. Balch; Jack R. Baum; Robert L. Boek; Robert T. Bramhall, Sr.; Charles T. Brown; Michael D. Byrne; Joel H. Campbell; Thomas P. Canastar; Nicholas A. Cerro; Denis J. Cimbal; Gary J. Corbett; Albert Cukierski; Gary J. Darstein; Dean C. Decker; Orlando M. D'Ella; Dominick DePaola, Jr.; Robert S. Dibble; Dennis P. Dougherty; Daniel D. Evans; Keith R. Fairchild; Russell C. Francis; Emanuel S. Friedman; Robert M. Fritzen; Dominick A. Froio, Jr.; Donald C. Geary; John W. Graham; Douglas E. Herrmann; Stanley A. Jung; Evelyn R. Kendrick; Robert J. Killough; Pascuale D. Lagatta; William L. Lefort; James E. Mathews; Norman J. Mattice; John R. Morlock; Lawrence J. Moylan; Christopher M. Murphy; Richard M. Owens; David Neil Paul; Leland J. Pavlot; Allen D. Piontkowski; Mario J. Restante; Eugene L. Rifenburg; James L. Rogers; Richard J. Sauer; Thomas L. Sears; William D. Slaughter; Douglas B. Smith; Roger W. Sykes; Scott W. Todd; Matthew A. Tynan; Michael Visco; Cornelius R. Walsh, Jr.; Robert D. Warner; Dexter B. Wassall; Stanley E. Weidman; Gerald J. Wendt; Milton A. White; Michael J. Yuzwak; John M. Moran; Christopher G. Allen; Thomas E. Alston, III; Craig Baldwin; Richard O. Bates; Lyle E. Baxter; Donald W. Berberich; Robert L. Beswick; Hugh L. Bigger; Sallie C. Bloomer; Joseph E. Bochnik; Alan T. Brock; Vincent T. Burke; William Caballero; Dennis M. Callahan; William T. Carey; Lawrence P. Chambers; Garfield Clark, Jr.; John M. Cleary, Jr.; Edward J. Collins; Frank Costa; Paul T. Decillis; Frank J. DeGennaro; Charles J. DePalma; Joseph W. Decker; Donald P. Delaney; James Docherty; Albert J. Drake; Bruce C. Dunning; James P. Aloi; Senior B. Auld; Joseph J. Barrett; Louis A. Battistello; Claus J. Bebensee; Robert J. Berry; Wayne E. Beyea; Daniel E. Bishop; Harold T. Bloomer, III; June M. Bradley; Herman C. Brown, Jr.; Thomas J. Butler; Patrick J. Caffery; Martin A. Card; Kevin D. Cavanagh; Rodger W. Chillemi; Robert F. Cleary; Neil A. Colello; Anthony Coppo; Lennie Daniels; Edward L. DeFisher; Solomon DeJesus; Charles J. Dechon; Louis R. Deltoro; John J. DiPofi; Randolph B. Donaldson; Henry H. Dunn; John P. Dunning; Elkan Eastman; Steven A. Ercole; Preston L. Felton; Stewart F. Field, Jr.; Mark Fischer; Gary F. Forshee; John E. Fuller; Albert G. Gerhart; Stanley R. Glover; Orlando V. Gonzalez; Harold Griffiths; Paul R. Hans; Gregory J. Harlin; Robert A. Hartmann; Robert B. Hayes; Robert Henderson; Russell G. Hicks; Walter T. Holloway; Wayne Huggler; Jorge J. Ibanez-Delgado; Salvatore Indelicatu; Paul T. Johnson; Kenneth T. Jones; George A. Jurak; Paul H. Kelly; Peter L. Kirk; Thomas G. Kleinhans; Anthony S. Kolakoski; George W. Elston; Roger L. Fairchild; David R. Ferringer; Carlos E. Figueroa; Mary E. Fitzpatrick; Charles W. Foster; Robert E. Fuller; Robert F. Giery; David H. Goggin; Gilbert N. Green, Jr.; John J. Grimmke; Jon B. Hansen; Edward C. Hartmann; Paul J. Hasselmann; Stephan A. Hegarty; Thomas K. Herrick; Jerome Holland; Joseph W. Holly; Johannes A. Hurbanek; Juan C. Inclan; Hector M. Jimenez; Douglas W. Johnstone; Lawrence Jonigan; Leonard C. Kasson; John M. Kennedy; Allan W. Kirkwood; Michael A. Klusacek; Charles F. Koran; Eric W. Kruger; Donna L. Lampert; George W. Lawson; Robert H. Lewis; Dominick A. Magro; Thomas D. Manaher; William J. Mante; Donald B. Markert; Charles A. Martin; Edward C. Martinez; John J. McCabe; Terrence P. McCormick; Roberto McFarlane; Thomas H. McHugh; Robert F. McLean; Thomas S. Meehan; Thomas J. Miller; Edward P. Moffe; Robert L. Monroe; William P. Morsheimer; Gregory Mosley; Martin Mulligan; James J. Murphy, Jr.; Stephen Nevins; Thaddeus A. Niksa; John J. Noonan; John O'Brien; John E. O'Keefe; Paul G. Kunar; John G. Lang; Christos G. Lecakes; Steven G. Louder; Issac A. Mallard; Michael T. Manning; David P. Marchitell; Dennis D. Marsh; Harold A. Martin; Robert A. Maurin; Donald T. McConville; John W. McCroary; Richard L. McGee; Charles J. McKenna; Charles J. McLoughlin; Jose A. Mendez; John R. Mitchell; Bruce A. Monforte; Gordon T. Mosher; Terrence F. Mullen; Robert W. Murphy; Reginald A. Nau; James J. Newell; Dennis J. Nolan; Vincent S. Notaro; William L. O'Brien; Terrence P. O'Mara; James P. O'Neill; Stephen J. Oates; John D. Odell; John A. Olquist; Michael Orrego; Ted M. Palmer; Stanley F. Pawelek; Robert R. Phenes; Robert E. Pineau; Edward Raso; George P. Rebhan; Daniel J. Regini; Louis E. Retzer; Jose Rivera; Robert W. Rochler; Michael J. Rogan; Mario A. Romain; Steve M. Sadowski; Paul M. Salvino; Bruce L. Schocken; George J. Schweikart; Richard L. Shearer; John H. Shultis; Roger D. Smith; Luis A. Soto; John P. Spencer, Jr.; Thomas Fred Starace; Roy L. Streever; Thomas M. O'Neill; Richard J. Ocenasek; Robert L. Odell; Richard Olsen; Steven Ortiz; William J. Palmer; Everett H. Pearsall; Kathleen R. Pierino; George C. Pinther; Gerald L. Rauber; Michael S. Reeves; Daniel J. Reidy; James M. Rielly; Robert S. Robles; Louis F. Rodriguez; Richard B. Rogers; Victor P. Rosati; Thomas F. Salmon; Errol I. Sasso; Robert L. Schraff; James Serrano; Lawrence A. Shewark, Jr.; Frederick H. Slanovec; Vincent J. Snyder; Dennis Spanitz; William G. Sprague; Jack S. Stenberg; Paul F. Sweetman; Patrick D. Sylvestre; Gerald Tiernan; Luis E. Torres; Derek Tudor; Dale A. Valentine; Luis Velez; Kevin W. Walsh; William R. Whalen; Thomas M. Wolf; Henry G. Youngblood; Richard D. Thurston; Jose L. Torres; Thomas C. Tucker; Michael R. Urbanski; John Vandermolen, Jr.; Robert T. Venezia; Donald K. Wentworth, Jr.; Arthur C. Wilson, III; Charles E. Wood; Thomas H. Zimmer, Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. Thomas A. CONSTANTINE, as Superintendent of the Division of the New York State Police; Division of the New York State Police; State of New York, Defendants-Appellants.