Nos. 3D10-439, 3D10-2317.
68 So.3d 944 (2011)

Helen REARICK, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Lana Parzyszek, Deceased, Appellant, v. R.J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANY and Philip Morris USA, Inc., Appellees.

District Court of Appeal of Florida, Third District.
Rehearing Denied September 22, 2011.

Gary, Williams, Finney, Lewis, Watson & Sperando and Paul D. Mark Lucas , Stuart and Marwan E. Porter ; Hunter, Williams & Lynch, Stuart, and Steven K. Hunter , and Christopher J. Lynch , Miami, for appellant.

Jones Day and Stephanie E. Parker and John F. Yarber ; Carlton Fields and Gary L. Sasso , Tampa and Joseph Hagedorn Lang, Jr. and Leah A. Sevi , Tallahassee, for appellees.

Before RAMIREZ and SUAREZ, JJ., and SCHWARTZ, Senior Judge.


Helen Rearick, etc., appeals the trial court's award of final summary judgment in favor of the appellees, R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company and Philip Morris USA, Inc., and the court's denial of her motion for relief from judgment in this wrongful death action brought on behalf of the survivors of her daughter Lana Parzyszek.

The case was filed under Engle v. Liggett Group, Inc., 945 So.2d 1246 (Fla.2006). Engle defined the class as "[a]ll Florida citizens and residents, and their survivors, who have suffered, presently suffer and who have died from diseases and medical conditions caused by their addiction to cigarettes that contain nicotine." Id. at 1274. The qualification for membership in the Engle class requires plaintiff to show that the decedent was a resident of the state of Florida at the time of a "medical diagnosis" of a smoking-related disease or at the time evidence of the causal relationship of the cause of action had [otherwise] manifested itself. Id. We affirm because there is no record evidence that Parzyszek's disease manifested itself during her Florida residency so as to satisfy the criteria for membership into the Engle class.

Parzyszek was born in Illinois in 1948. She lived in Florida from approximately late in 1987 or early 1988 until she moved to Illinois to live with her mother in approximately late 1991 or early 1992. In August of 1993, she was diagnosed in Illinois with lung cancer. She received treatment there until her death in 1993.

Rearick filed the underlying wrongful death action on January 11, 2008. The defendants moved for summary judgment on the grounds that Rearick's claim was time-barred because Parzyszek was not an Engle class member and as a result, the wrongful death action filed in 2008, fifteen years after her death, was untimely. In essence, the defendants argued that undisputed evidence showed that Parzyszek was not an Engle class member because she was not a Florida citizen or resident when she was diagnosed with lung cancer in 1993.

Rearick argued that the claim was timely since it was filed within one year of the Engle mandate. Because Parzyszek suffered from a smoking-related disease while a resident of Florida, she qualified as a member of the Engle class. Rearick relied upon affidavits and deposition testimony which showed that Parzyszek exhibited smoking-related symptoms, such as breathing problems and a severe cough, and was suffering from bronchitis, a form of COPD, as well as lung cancer, both smoking related diseases, during the term of her Florida residency.

Defendants counter that Rearick's contention that Parzyszek first manifested the disease during her Florida residency could not prevent the entry of summary judgment because it was based on two expert affidavits that used the term "manifested" in a manner that is contrary to the legal definition of the term, which the defendants asserted, was required by Engle. Furthermore, even if Parzyszek's disease had "manifested" itself as early as 1988, Rearick's claim would still be time-barred by Florida's four-year statute of limitations, section 95.11(3)(a), Florida Statutes (2011), which would have run in 1992, two years prior to the filing of the original Engle complaint.

The court entered summary judgment in favor of the defendants on the ground that record evidence shows that Parzyszek's disease did not first manifest itself during her Florida residency. The court reasoned that Parzyszek's arguments and expert affidavits submitted in opposition to summary judgment used the term "manifestation" in a manner not in accordance with Florida law, and that, even if Parzyszek's claims manifested as early as 1988, to the extent that Rearick's claims arose more than four years prior to the filing of the Engle class action in 1994, they would be time-barred as a result of Florida's four-year statute of limitations.

Subsequently, Rearick filed a motion for relief from the final summary judgment. She asserted that newly discovered evidence in the form of the identification of a treating Florida physician, Dr. Ronald Chassner, an orthopedic surgeon, indicated that Parzyszek's treatment with him in Florida supported Rearick's contention that Parzyszek was an Engle class member.

The court denied the motion, concluding that there was no evidence that counsel exercised due diligence in locating and speaking with Dr. Chassner, and that, in any event, Dr. Chassner's affidavit did not provide any evidence that Parzyszek's alleged smoking-related injury manifested while she was a resident of Florida.

We conclude that Rearick's claim is untimely, and thus Parzyszek does not qualify as an Engle class member. Parzyszek is a long-time Illinois resident who now attempts to prosecute an untimely claim with the Florida-only class of Engle. In Engle, the Florida Supreme Court required "manifestation" of a smoking-related disease or medical condition in Florida. The record before us does not reflect that Parzyszek suffered from a smoking-related disease or medical condition while she was a resident of the State of Florida, even if we include the newly-discovered testimony of Dr. Chassner. Parzyszek's smoking-related condition would have manifested itself as early as 1987 or 1988, the time during which Parzyszek moved to Florida. Rearick filed her lawsuit in 2008. This is more than four years after the statute of limitations period for Engle class membership. Rearick's lawsuit was thus time-barred. Therefore, we affirm.



1000 Characters Remaining reserves the right to edit or remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

User Comments

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases