OMNI HEALTHCARE INC. v. HEALTH FIRST, INC.

Case No. 6:13-cv-1509-Orl-37DAB.

OMNI HEALTHCARE INC.; INTERVENTIONAL SPINE INSTITUTE OF FLORIDA; CRAIG DELIGDISH; C. HAMILTON BOONE, PA; BRIAN DOWDELL; RICHARD GAYLES; STAN GOLOVAC; LANCE GRENEVICKI; ALEKSANDER KOMAR; SCOTT SEMINER; INSTITUTE OF FACIAL SURGERY INC.; THE PAIN INSTITUTE INC.; and PHYSICIAN ASSISTANT SERVICES OF FLORIDA, LLC, Plaintiffs, v. HEALTH FIRST, INC.; HOLMES REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, INC.; HEALTH FIRST PHYSICIANS, INC.; HEALTH FIRST HEALTH PLANS, INC.; MICHAEL D. MEANS; and JERRY SENNE, Defendants.

United States District Court, M.D. Florida, Orlando Division.

August 13, 2016.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

Omni Healthcare Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA, William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC, Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

Interventional Spine Institute of Florida, Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA, William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC, Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

Craig Deligdish, Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA, William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC, Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

C. Hamilton Boone, PA, Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA, William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC, Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

Brian Dowell, Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA, William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC, Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

Richard Gayles, Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA, William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC, Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

Stan Golovac, Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA, William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC, Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

Lance Grenevicki, Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA, William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC, Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

Aleksander Komar, Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA, William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC, Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

Scott Seminer, Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA, William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC, Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

Institute of Facial Surgery Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA, William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC, Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

The Pain Institute Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA.

The Pain Institute Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA.

The Pain Institute Inc., Plaintiff, represented by William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA & Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC.

The Pain Institute Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice.

The Pain Institute Inc., Plaintiff, represented by Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

Physician Assistant Services of Florida, LLC, Plaintiff, represented by Damien Hunter Prosser , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Jessica Lea Thorson , Morgan & Morgan, PA, William B. Lewis , Morgan & Morgan, PA, Charles Nicholas Dorman , Whatley Kallas, LLC, Deborah J. Winegard , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Derrick Jamie Carruth , Whatley Kallas, LLC, pro hac vice, Edith M. Kallas , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice, Henry C. Quillen , Whatley Kallas, LLP, Joe R. Whatley, Jr. , Whatley Kallas, LLP, pro hac vice & Patrick J. Sheehan , Whatley Kallas, LLP.

Health First, Inc., Defendant, represented by Anna T. Neill , Kenny Nachwalter, PA, Dominic C. MacKenzie , Holland & Knight, LLP, James T. Almon , Kenny Nachwalter, PA, Jerome W. Hoffman , Holland & Knight, LLP, Kevin W. Cox , Holland & Knight, LLP, Mia Loraine McKown , Holland & Knight, LLP & Richard Alan Arnold , Kenny Nachwalter, PA.

Holmes Regional Medical Center, Inc., Defendant, represented by Anna T. Neill , Kenny Nachwalter, PA, Dominic C. MacKenzie , Holland & Knight, LLP, James T. Almon , Kenny Nachwalter, PA, Jerome W. Hoffman , Holland & Knight, LLP, Kevin W. Cox , Holland & Knight, LLP, Mia Loraine McKown , Holland & Knight, LLP & Richard Alan Arnold , Kenny Nachwalter, PA.

Health First Physicians, Inc., Defendant, represented by Anna T. Neill , Kenny Nachwalter, PA, Dominic C. MacKenzie , Holland & Knight, LLP, James T. Almon , Kenny Nachwalter, PA, Jerome W. Hoffman , Holland & Knight, LLP, Kevin W. Cox , Holland & Knight, LLP, Mia Loraine McKown , Holland & Knight, LLP & Richard Alan Arnold , Kenny Nachwalter, PA.

Health First Health Plans, Inc., Defendant, represented by Anna T. Neill , Kenny Nachwalter, PA, Dominic C. MacKenzie , Holland & Knight, LLP, James T. Almon , Kenny Nachwalter, PA, Jerome W. Hoffman , Holland & Knight, LLP, Kevin W. Cox , Holland & Knight, LLP, Mia Loraine McKown , Holland & Knight, LLP & Richard Alan Arnold , Kenny Nachwalter, PA.

Michael D. Means, Defendant, represented by Daniel Cramer Brown , Carlton Fields Jorden Burt, PA, Dominic C. MacKenzie , Holland & Knight, LLP, Jerome W. Hoffman , Holland & Knight, LLP, Kevin W. Cox , Holland & Knight, LLP & Mia Loraine McKown , Holland & Knight, LLP.

Jerry Senne, Defendant, represented by Frank Moor Bedell , Frank M. Bedell, PA, Helen Peacock Roberson , Tanner Bishop, Michael G. Tanner , Tanner Bishop & Thomas Edward Bishop , Tanner Bishop.

Tampa Pain Relief Center, Inc., Third Party Custodian, represented by Matthew Grosack , DLA Piper US, LLP.


ORDER

This cause is before the Court on the following:

1. Plaintiffs' Daubert Motion to Exclude Defendants' Expert Testimony and Incorporated Memorandum of Law (Doc. 197), filed January 22, 2016; 2. Corporate Defendants' Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Daubert

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases