AMERICAN CASUALTY COMPANY OF READING v. ALLEN

Case No. 2:12-CV-2414-SLB.

AMERICAN CASUALTY COMPANY OF READING, PENNSYLVANIA, Plaintiffs, v. DAVID L. ALLEN; et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, N.D. Alabama, Southern Division.

September 29, 2015.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

American Casualty Company of Reading Pennsylavania, Plaintiff, represented by Richard A Simpson , WILEY REIN LLP & Elizabeth Ann McMahan , SIMPSON, MCMAHAN, GLICK & BURFORD PLLC.

David L Allen, Defendant, represented by James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON & Michael C Shores .

Bonnie Allinder, Defendant, represented by Robert R Riley, Jr , RILEY & JACKSON PC & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Willie Jean Armstrong, Defendant, represented by Robert R Riley, Jr , RILEY & JACKSON PC & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Anna Calkins, Defendant, represented by Robert R Riley, Jr , RILEY & JACKSON PC & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Dillie Rae Culberson, as Executrix of the Estate of Eleanor Ray Harrison, Defendant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC & William P Traylor, III , YEAROUT & TRAYLOR PC.

David Bernard Evans, as Administrator of the Estate of Columbus Evans, Defendant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC, David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP & James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON.

Lillie Ann Fancher, as Parent and Co-Administrator of the Estate of Darryl Joe Fancher, Defendant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC, David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP, James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON & Shay Samples , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON LLP.

Joe Fancher, as Parent and Co-Administrator of the Estate of Darryl Joe Fancher, Defendant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC, David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP & James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON.

Wanda Fowler, as Personal Representative of teh Estate of Robert Ernest Fowler, Defendant, represented by Robert R Riley, Jr , RILEY & JACKSON PC & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Robert Ernest Fowler, Defendant, represented by Robert R Riley, Jr , RILEY & JACKSON PC & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Ida Gipson, Defendant, represented by Robert R Riley, Jr , RILEY & JACKSON PC & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Lelon Harris, Defendant, represented by Gayle L Douglas , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS LLC, Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC & William L Bross, IV , HENINGER GARRISON & DAVIS LLC.

Shirley Haynesworth, as Power of Attorney for and on behalf of Todd Hammond, Defendant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC, David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP, James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON & Shay Samples , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON LLP.

Todd Hammond, Defendant, represented by David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP, James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON & Shay Samples , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON LLP.

V Michele Leonard, on behalf of Edith Carter, Defendant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Edith Carter, Defendant, represented by Robert P Bruner , BELT & BRUNER P.C. & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Patricia Ann Mainor, as Administratrix of the Estsate of Frances Bray Jones, Defendant, represented by Kenneth E Riley , FARRIS RILEY & PITT LLP & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Donald J Mottern, Defendant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC, David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP, James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON & Shay Samples , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON LLP.

Lavonne S Mottern, Defendant, represented by David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP, James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON & Shay Samples , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON LLP.

Alice F Nixon, Defendant, represented by Roger D Burton , ROGER D BURTON PC & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Chester Robinson, Defendant, represented by Patrick M Lavette , DAVENPORT LAVETTE & CLECKLER PC & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Lydal Robinson, as Personal Representative of the State of Jewell Robinson, Defendant, represented by Gayle L Douglas , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS LLC, Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC & William L Bross, IV , HENINGER GARRISON & DAVIS LLC.

Cora P Sheppard, as Personal Representative of the Lunna Powell, Defendant, represented by Jason A Shamblin , ALLEN & SHAMBLIN LLC, Leila H Watson , CORY WATSON CROWDER & DEGARIS PC & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Steven C Smith, as Personal Representative of the Estate of of Dale McAfee Tidwell, Defendant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC & Zeb P Little , ZEB LITTLE LAW LLC.

Lori Ellyn Steber, Defendant, represented by Jarrod D Nichols , JARROD D NICHOLS PC & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Gina Yeager, Defendant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC, David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP & James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON.

Harvey R Young, as administrator of the Estate of Carol Ann Young, Defendant, represented by Robert P Bruner , BELT & BRUNER P.C. & Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC.

Linda L Huebner, as Administratrix of the Estate of Joseph Scarborough, substituted see order [51], Defendant, represented by Gayle L Douglas , HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS LLC, Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC & William L Bross, IV , HENINGER GARRISON & DAVIS LLC.

Todd Hammond, Counter Claimant, represented by David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP, James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON & Shay Samples , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON LLP.

Joe Fancher, as Parent and Co-Administrator of the Estate of Darryl Joe Fancher, Counter Claimant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC, David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP & James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON.

Gina Yeager, Counter Claimant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC, David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP & James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON.

Donald J Mottern, Counter Claimant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC, David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP, James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON & Shay Samples , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON LLP.

Lavonne S Mottern, Counter Claimant, represented by David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP, James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON & Shay Samples , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON LLP.

Shirley Haynesworth, as Power of Attorney for and on behalf of Todd Hammond, Counter Claimant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC, David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP, James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON & Shay Samples , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON LLP.

David Bernard Evans, as Administrator of the Estate of Columbus Evans, Counter Claimant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC, David Leon Ashford , HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, LLP & James R Moncus, III , HARE WYNN NEWELL & NEWTON.

American Casualty Company of Reading Pennsylavania, Counter Defendant, represented by Richard A Simpson , WILEY REIN LLP & Elizabeth Ann McMahan , SIMPSON, MCMAHAN, GLICK & BURFORD PLLC.

Dillie Rae Culberson, as Executrix of the Estate of Eleanor Ray Harrison, Counter Claimant, represented by Samuel H Franklin , LIGHTFOOT FRANKLIN & WHITE LLC & William P Traylor, III , YEAROUT & TRAYLOR PC.

American Casualty Company of Reading Pennsylavania, Counter Defendant, represented by Richard A Simpson , WILEY REIN LLP & Elizabeth Ann McMahan , SIMPSON, MCMAHAN, GLICK & BURFORD PLLC.


MEMORANDUM OPINION

This case is presently pending before the court on plaintiff's Objections, (doc. 109),1 to the Magistrate Judge's Report and Recommendation, (doc. 108). Plaintiff, American Casualty Company of Reading, Pennsylvania,...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases