BRENNER v. SCOTT

Consolidated Case No. 4:14cv107-RH/CAS.

JAMES DOMER BRENNER et al., Plaintiffs, v. RICK SCOTT, etc., et al., Defendants.

United States District Court, N.D. Florida, Tallahassee Division.

January 1, 2015.


Attorney(s) appearing for the Case

JAMES DOMER BRENNER, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN EVERETT DEMAGGIO , SHEPPARD WHITE ETC PA, SAMUEL S JACOBSON , BLEDSOE JACOBSON SCHMIDT ETC PA & WILLIAM J SHEPPARD , SHEPPARD WHITE ETC PA.

CHARLES DEAN JONES, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN EVERETT DEMAGGIO , SHEPPARD WHITE ETC PA, SAMUEL S JACOBSON , BLEDSOE JACOBSON SCHMIDT ETC PA & WILLIAM J SHEPPARD , SHEPPARD WHITE ETC PA.

STEPHEN SCHLAIRET, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN EVERETT DEMAGGIO , SHEPPARD WHITE ETC PA, SAMUEL S JACOBSON , BLEDSOE JACOBSON SCHMIDT ETC PA & WILLIAM J SHEPPARD , SHEPPARD WHITE ETC PA.

OZZIE RUSS, Plaintiff, represented by BRYAN EVERETT DEMAGGIO , SHEPPARD WHITE ETC PA, SAMUEL S JACOBSON , BLEDSOE JACOBSON SCHMIDT ETC PA & WILLIAM J SHEPPARD , SHEPPARD WHITE ETC PA.

SLOAN GRIMSLEY, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

JOYCE ALBU, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

BOB COLLIER, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

CHUCK HUNZIKER, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

LINDSAY MYERS, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

SARAH HUMLIE, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

ROBERT LOUPO, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

JOHN FITZGERALD, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

DENISE HUESO, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

SANDRA NEWSON, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

JUAN DEL HIERRO, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

THOMAS GANTT, JR, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

CHRISTIAN ULVERT, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

CARLOS ANDRADE, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

RICHARD MILSTEIN, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

ERIC HANKIN, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

ARLENE GOLDBERG, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

SAVE FOUNDATION INC, Plaintiff, represented by DANIEL BOAZ TILLEY , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC, MARIA KAYANAN , ACLU FOUNDATION OF FLORIDA INC & STEPHEN FREDERICK ROSENTHAL , PODHURST ORSECK PA.

GOVERNOR RICK SCOTT, Defendant, represented by ALLEN C WINSOR , FLORIDA ATTORNEY GENERAL - TALLAHASSEE FL & ADAM SCOTT TANENBAUM , ATTORNEY GENERAL.

PAMELA BONDI, Defendant, represented by ALLEN C WINSOR , FLORIDA ATTORNEY GENERAL - TALLAHASSEE FL & ADAM SCOTT TANENBAUM , ATTORNEY GENERAL.

JOHN H ARMSTRONG, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS SURGEON GENERAL AND SECRETARY OF HEALTH FOR THE STATE OF FLORIDA, Defendant, represented by ALLEN C WINSOR , FLORIDA ATTORNEY GENERAL - TALLAHASSEE FL & ADAM SCOTT TANENBAUM , ATTORNEY GENERAL.

CRAIG J NICHOLS, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS AGENCY SECRETARY FOR THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF MANAGEMENT SERVICES, Defendant, represented by ALLEN C WINSOR , FLORIDA ATTORNEY GENERAL - TALLAHASSEE FL & ADAM SCOTT TANENBAUM , ATTORNEY GENERAL.

HAROLD BAZZELL, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS CLERK OF COURT AND COMPTROLLER FOR WASHINGTON COUNTY FLORIDA, Defendant, represented by JAMES JEFFERY GOODMAN, JR , JEFF GOODMAN PA.

FLORIDA FAMILY ACTION INC, Amicus, represented by HORATIO G. MIHET , LIBERTY COUNSEL.

FLORIDA CONFERENCE OF CATHOLIC BISHOPS, INC., Amicus, represented by STEPHEN C EMMANUEL , AUSLEY & MCMULLEN.


ORDER ON THE SCOPE OF THE PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

ROBERT L. HINKLE, District Judge.

In this consolidated case, the plaintiffs challenge provisions of the Florida Constitution and Florida Statutes banning same-sex marriage. Two plaintiffs are unmarried; they seek issuance of a Florida marriage license. The other plaintiffs are individuals (and an association representing individuals) who were married in other jurisdictions and seek recognition...

Let's get started

Leagle.com

Welcome to the leading source of independent legal reporting
Sign on now to see your case.
Or view more than 10 million decisions and orders.

  • Updated daily.
  • Uncompromising quality.
  • Complete, Accurate, Current.

Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. Citations are also linked in the body of the Featured Case.

Cited Cases

  • No Cases Found

Listed below are those cases in which this Featured Case is cited. Click on the case name to see the full text of the citing case.

Citing Cases